Hmm… you really don’t want to go for the first because if he likes you AND another girl..forget about it…you want someone who likes YOU and ONLY YOU! The second guy may be shy…but if he knows you like him and hasn’t said anything, it’s either he’s reallly shy or he probably doesn’t feel the same :( i know that sucks but that’s life…i think you should confront the second guy and find out whats going on because if you don’t say anything you’ll be left wondering and that will hurt a lot…hope this helped :)